Butt Plugs

Do you have what it takes to adopt one of our premium anal play toys? These stimulating anal plugs and adult toys need a quality home, and each one is guaranteed to challenge your erotic limits. Buy a quality anal sex toy today and enjoy 100% fulfillment!

Clear all filters

Showing 108 of 108 products

Sort by:
Price Reset
Price: 0 – $299.99
Product type Reset
Color Reset
Availability Reset
Filter and sort

Filter and sort

Showing 108 of 108 products

Price

Up to $299.99

Clear
Product type
Clear
Color
Clear
Availability
Clear
Clear all filters
Clear all filters
Showing 108 of 108 products
  • Sport Fucker Thunder Plug Asslock Blue Anal Products

    Sport Fucker Thunder Plug Asslock

    $46.00
    $46.00
  • Satisfyer Plug-ilicious 2 - Berry, Black, or Ice Blue: Vibrating Anal Plug with Dual Motors and App Control for Ultimate Anal Pleasure

    Satisfyer Plug-ilicious 2 - Berry, Black, or Ice Blue: Vibrating Anal Plug with Dual Motors and App Control for Ultimate Anal Pleasure

    $69.95
    $69.95
  • Satisfyer Plug-ilicious 1: Vibrating Anal Plug with Dual Motors for Intense Anal Pleasure

    Satisfyer Plug-ilicious 1: Vibrating Anal Plug with Dual Motors for Intense Anal Pleasure

    $69.95
    $69.95
  • Rear Assets Rose Gold

    Rear Assets Rose Gold

    From $11.39
    From $11.39
  • Pretty Love Beginner's Mini Anal Kit - Black Set of 3 Anal Products

    Pretty Love Beginner's Mini Anal Kit - Black: Perfect for Exploring New Sensations

    $45.59
    $45.59
  • Oxballs Ergo Buttplug Large / Platinum Swirl Gay & Lesbian Products

    Oxballs Ergo Buttplug: Ultimate Prostate Pleasure

    From $32.00
    From $32.00
    $46.08
  • Nixie Metal Butt Plug W/inlaid Jewel & Fur Cuff Set Blue Metallic Bondage Blindfolds & Restraints

    Nixie Metal Butt Plug W/inlaid Jewel & Fur Cuff Set: Elegant and Sensual Bondage Play

    $30.89
    $30.89
    $37.07
  • Nexus Simul8 Plug - Black Penis Enhancement

    Nexus Simul8 Plug - Black: Ultimate Dual Stimulation

    $86.99
    $86.99
    $125.27
  • Nexus Bolster Butt Plug w/Inflatable Tip - Black Anal Products

    Nexus Bolster Butt Plug w/Inflatable Tip - Black: Elevated Prostate Pleasure

    $144.99
    $144.99
    $208.79
  • Nexus Beginner Anal Kit - Black Anal Products

    Nexus Beginner Anal Kit - Black: Your Ultimate Starter Set for Anal Play

    $43.49
    $43.49
    $62.63
  • Satisfyer Game Changer: Ultimate Stimulation for All Your Desires

    Satisfyer Game Changer: Ultimate Stimulation for All Your Desires

    $69.95
    $69.95
  • Satisfyer Backdoor Lover: Intense Anal Pleasure in Red or Black

    Satisfyer Backdoor Lover: Intense Anal Pleasure in Red or Black

    $49.95
    $49.95
  • Satisfyer Power Plug - Plum: Powerful Anal Vibrator with App Control for Intense Backdoor Stimulation

    Satisfyer Power Plug - Plum: Powerful Anal Vibrator with App Control for Intense Backdoor Stimulation

    $69.95
    $69.95
  • Satisfyer Intensity Plug - Gold or Purple: Vibrating Butt Plug with Adjustable Vibration and App Control

    Satisfyer Intensity Plug - Gold or Purple: Vibrating Butt Plug with Adjustable Vibration and App Control

    $69.95
    $69.95
  • Satisfyer Lolli Plug: Vibrating Anal Plug with Dual Motors for Intense Backdoor Stimulation

    Satisfyer Lolli Plug: Vibrating Anal Plug with Dual Motors for Intense Backdoor Stimulation

    $49.95
    $49.95
  • Satisfyer Plug Set Of 3 - Black: Perfect Starter Pack for Anal Play Exploration

    Satisfyer Plug Set Of 3 - Black: Perfect Starter Pack for Anal Play Exploration

    $29.95
    $29.95
  • Bang! Glow in the Dark 21X Remote Controlled Butt Plug: Illuminate Your Pleasure

    Bang! Glow in the Dark 21X Remote Controlled Butt Plug: Illuminate Your Pleasure

    $59.99
    $59.99
  • Habiki Hollowed Vibrating Anal Plug Anal Products

    Habiki Hollowed Vibrating Anal Plug: Enhanced Pleasure with Cutting-Edge Technology

    $68.99
    $68.99
    $99.35
  • GoodHead Party Pack - 5 pc Kit Sexual Enhancers

    GoodHead Party Pack - 5 pc Kit: The Ultimate Oral Adventure Kit

    $32.63
    $32.63
  • Glas Pleasure Droplets Anal Training Kit Anal Products

    Glas Pleasure Droplets Anal Training Kit: Graduated Sizes for Evolving Pleasure

    $79.99
    $79.99
  • Glas Helmet Head Anal Training Kit - Set of 3 Anal Products

    Glas Helmet Head Anal Training Kit - Set of 3: Graduated Pleasure for Every Level

    $89.99
    $89.99
  • Glas 4 pc Mr. Swirly Set w/Glass Kegel Balls & 3.25" Butt Plug - Red Dongs & Dildos

    Glas 4 Pc Mr. Swirly Set with Glass Kegel Balls & 3.25" Butt Plug in Red: Comprehensive Pleasure Kit

    $67.99
    $67.99
  • Glas 3 pc Rosebud Butt Plug Set - Pink Anal Products

    Glas 3 Pc Rosebud Butt Plug Set in Pink: Gradual Elegance for Enhanced Play

    $89.99
    $89.99
  • Glas 3 pc Heart Jewel Glass Anal Training Kit Anal Products

    Glas 3 Pc Heart Jewel Glass Anal Training Kit: Elegance in Exploration

    $89.99
    $89.99
  • Glas 10" Mr. Swirly Double Ended Glass Dildo & Butt P Dongs & Dildos

    Glas 10" Mr. Swirly Double Ended Glass Dildo & Butt Plug: Dual Delight

    $35.99
    $35.99
  • Glas 3.5" Rechargeable Vibrating Beaded Butt Plug - Blue Anal Products

    Glas 3.5" Rechargeable Vibrating Beaded Butt Plug in Blue: Dynamic Pleasure for Beginners

    $99.99
    $99.99
  • Glas 4" Rechargeable Vibrating Dotted G Spot/P Spot Plug - Blue Anal Products

    Glas 4" Rechargeable Vibrating Dotted G Spot/P Spot Plug in Blue: Precision Pleasure

    $99.99
    $99.99
    $143.99
  • Glas 3.5" Rechargeable Vibrating Butt Plug - Blue Anal Products

    Glas 3.5" Rechargeable Vibrating Butt Plug in Blue: Enhance Your Exploration

    $99.99
    $99.99
  • Glas 3 pc Glass Anal Training Kit Anal Products

    Glas 3 Pc Glass Anal Training Kit: Step-by-Step Elegance for Exploration

    $52.99
    $52.99
  • Glas Pacifier Glass Butt Plug Anal Products

    Glas Pacifier Glass Butt Plug: Discreet Design, Unforgettable Pleasure

    $25.99
    $25.99
  • Glas Galileo Glass Butt Plug Anal Products

    Glas Galileo Glass Butt Plug: A Masterpiece of Pleasure

    $29.99
    $29.99
  • Glas Quintessence Beaded Glass Anal Slider Anal Products

    Glas Quintessence Beaded Glass Anal Slider: Smooth, Graduated Pleasure

    $35.99
    $35.99
  • Glas Amethyst Rain Glass Butt Plug Anal Products

    Glas Amethyst Rain Glass Butt Plug: Aesthetic Pleasure Meets Intense Stimulation

    $24.99
    $24.99
  • Glas Over Easy Butt Plug Anal Products

    Glas Over Easy Butt Plug: Classic Design Meets Artistic Elegance

    $29.99
    $29.99
  • Glas 7.25" Glass Beaded Butt Plug - Clear Anal Products

    Glas 7.25" Glass Beaded Butt Plug - Clear: A Symphony of Sensations

    $59.99
    $59.99
  • Glas Titus Beaded Glass Butt Plug Anal Products

    Glas Titus Beaded Glass Butt Plug: Elegant Versatility in Glass

    $30.99
    $30.99
  • Glas 5" Fist Butt Plug Anal Products

    Glas 5" Fist Butt Plug: Dare to Indulge in Thrilling Sensations

    $49.99
    $49.99
  • Glas 3.5" Bling Bling Glass Butt Plug - Clear Anal Products

    Glas 3.5" Bling Bling Glass Butt Plug in Clear: Sparkle as You Play

    $31.99
    $31.99
  • Glas 5" Rosebud Glass Butt Plug - Pink Anal Products

    Glas 5" Rosebud Glass Butt Plug - Pink: A Blooming Pleasure for Beginners

    $35.99
    $35.99
  • Glas 4" Classic Butt Plug - Clear Anal Products

    Glas 4" Classic Butt Plug in Clear: Timeless Elegance for Anal Exploration

    $27.99
    $27.99
  • Glas 4" Beaded Glass Butt Plug w/Tapered Base - Clear Anal Products

    Glas 4" Beaded Glass Butt Plug with Tapered Base in Clear: Step-by-Step Satisfaction

    $30.99
    $30.99
  • Glas Triple Play Beaded Butt Plug - Clear Anal Products

    Glas Triple Play Beaded Butt Plug - Clear: Classic Elegance, Enhanced Sensations

    $30.99
    $30.99
  • Glas 5" Juicer - Clear Anal Products

    Glas 5" Juicer - Clear: Exquisite Sensations with Artisan Craftsmanship

    $23.99
    $23.99
  • Glas Butt Plug - Clear 4" Anal Products

    Glas Butt Plug - Clear: Simple Perfection for Temperature Play

    $23.99
    $23.99
  • Booty Bling Wearable Silicone Beads Pink Anal Products

    Booty Bling Wearable Silicone Beads: Enhance Your Pleasure

    $30.21
    $30.21

A Plug For Every Butt

Whether you want them long or short, thick or thin, with ridges or without, we have a premium butt plug just for you! Step right up and explore a collection of products from quality manufacturers made with body-safe materials like glass, stainless steel, and medical-grade silicone rubber that is chemical-free and safe for intimate contact. You’ll find realistic silicone dicks, impudent dongs, streamlined rods, and beaded explorers with special features like vibrating, flicking, throbbing, and more. Order one now and get some fun between the buns!

Adult Toys for Men

There’s more for men than anal play toys at Nite Toys, and our selection of men’s sexual toys and supplies covers all of your needs! Our emporium supports the sexual health of men by providing a large collection of therapeutic products that are healthy and safe to use. We carry reasonably priced toys with luxuriously textured surfaces, vibrating features, and many special abilities. We have a large inventory of strokers, fantasy masturbators, men’s cock rings, premium prostate massagers, and more. Buy one today for yourself or a friend!

Adult Toys for Women

Thousands of women enter our online store every day looking for sexual satisfaction. They know where to buy the best anal sex toy, and where they can find advanced adult anal play toys like vibrating plugs, remote-controlled pegs, and comfortable trainers. They appreciate the value of Nite Toys products, and the performance of top brands like LELO, Blush, We-Vibe, and others. Our inventory of elegant toys includes bullets, vibrators, clitoris stimulators, personal lubricants, sexy nightwear, and more! Heat up your partner with seductive lingerie and see how long you can wear it! 

Adult Toys for Couples

The adult toys for couples in our store are finely crafted and need a home just as much as our incredible anal play toys. Our shelves carry the finest examples of adult erotic products, with couple’s toys like spicy bondage bears, naughty bedroom games you play with a hard-on, and games for dirty minds. We carry a variety of fun sex toys for couples, including cock rings for two, strap-ons, couples vibrators, strapless rabbits, double-ended dildos, and more! Order one or more today and let these fun toys enhance your intimacy and draw you closer together.

Our Mission 

At Nite Toys we go the extra mile in providing quality toys and products for adults who are seeking sexual relief and healthy exercise alone or with a friend. When you buy an adult anal plug or other sex toy for erotic play from Nite Toys you are making an investment in your sexual health and wellbeing. We’ll do everything we can to help, with top-quality, reasonably priced products, and free shipping on orders that are more than $69, plus a gift valued at $20 or more! We want you to experience the utmost pleasure, so order a toy today!

Contact Us 

If you have questions about anal play toys, contact customer service. For more information about discrete sex toys or our business, see our About Us page.